Wayne Besen - Daily Commentary

Friday, February 17, 2006

A recent Zogby poll suggests 47 percent of all Americans surveyed believe all people have the potential to be sexually attracted to members of both sexes. The nationwide poll, commissioned by Scientific American's Mind magazine, showed only 11 percent of those asked believe sexual orientation is a conscious choice, while 34 percent said it is determined by both choice and other factors and 6 percent weren't sure, United Press International reported.

While expressing a widespread belief that sexual orientation is not an active choice, 47 percent of respondents agreed with the statement, "I believe that all people have the potential to be sexually attracted to members of both sexes." A distinct majority, 53 percent, said they believe "a straight person may occasionally experience sexual attraction to individuals of the same sex."

In my opinion, the poll is screwed up. I simply don't believe that 53 percent of people said they felt this way. It defies reason and common sense.

8 Comments:

Wayne, do you not realize the genie that's been let out of the bottle here?

When the New York magazine is running eight-page stories that feature this:

"Of course, what can’t be expressed in statistical terms is how teenagers think about their same-sex interactions. Go to the schools, talk to the kids, and you’ll see that somewhere along the line this generation has started to conceive of sexuality differently. Ten years ago in the halls of Stuyvesant you might have found a few goth girls kissing goth girls, kids on the fringes defiantly bucking the system. Now you find a group of vaguely progressive but generally mainstream kids for whom same-sex intimacy is standard operating procedure. “It’s not like, Oh, I’m going to hit on her now. It’s just kind of like, you come up to a friend, you grab their ass,” Alair explains. “It’s just, like, our way of saying hello.” These teenagers don’t feel as though their sexuality has to define them, or that they have to define it, which has led some psychologists and child-development specialists to label them the “post-gay” generation. But kids like Alair and her friends are in the process of working up their own language to describe their behavior. Along with gay, straight, and bisexual, they’ll drop in new words, some of which they’ve coined themselves: polysexual, ambisexual, pansexual, pansensual, polyfide, bi-curious, bi-queer, fluid, metroflexible, heteroflexible, heterosexual with lesbian tendencies—or, as Alair puts it, “just sexual.” The terms are designed less to achieve specificity than to leave all options open."

...how in the world are you going to expect people NOT to start answering polls the way this is being reported?
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 2/17/2006 11:22 AM  

The "post-gay" generation?
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 2/17/2006 11:24 AM  

boo, you're right...men and women are indeed created quite differently.
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 2/17/2006 12:03 PM  

Anonymous - I have to let you know that I don't respect your research technique. What you do is derisively referred to as "scratch and sniff" research.

People who use this "technique" begin with a conclusion, and then desperately scratch the surface and scour the Internet for "proof" to back their pre-ordained assertions.

But, the truth is, anyone with half a brain can find something on the Internet to back his or her viewpoint. If I wanted to find a person who thinks he is an allen, I could do so with the click of a mouse. But that would be essentially meaningless, now wouldn't it?

Your research technique can be summed up: "I read it on the Internet, thererfore I beleive it, and it must be true." Of course, this is without context, real-world experience and common sense.

With all due respect, that is the way dilettantes and dolts do research. No wonder why you don't sign your name, you are rightfully ashamed of who you are, what you do and the way you do it.
posted by Blogger Wayne Besen, at 2/17/2006 12:31 PM  

Kind of interesting that I "cited" a link that has seven pages, while you don't even have a link for the Zogby data. Where did you read that? Fax? E-mail? Zogby's infallibility has been called into question before, hasn't it?

And again, since you're the one doing the name calling you're just saying that you've got nothing to refute the argument.

Come on, Wayne...what if the youth of today and the future could grow up without the pressures GLBT youth faced? If a by-product of that was the unwillingness to have a label and the freedom to love whomever they wanted (as long as that person is a consenting, non-unfaithful-to-a-spouse adult) is that so bad?

Or is there a more serious reason that this bothers you? Could it possibly be that these same people might not need you anymore, Wayne?
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 2/17/2006 1:59 PM  

ANON: Men and women were not "created". We evolved. There's a big difference, and wildly different implications follow. Just my two-cents. And as for Wayne Besen and people like him, he's needed more these days than ever before! The country is stewing in its ignorance, and it is quite refreshing to hear ideas which come from someone who isn't brainwashed by religious mythology or other such absurdities.

Whoever you are, I don't know, but you should be true to yourself and live a life of honesty. Do yourself a favor and stop worrying that some man in the sky will torture you for all eternity if you should decide to live an authentic existence.
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 2/17/2006 2:25 PM  

The Zogby poll was done for this article:

"Do Gays Have a Choice?" from the February/March Issue of Scientific American Mind (on newstands Feb.2 see link below). The sexual orientation quiz was provided Robert Epstein, the author of the article.

http://www.sciammind.com/article.cfm?articleID=00062352-4947-13D9-810183414B7F0000

QUIZ: How Gay Are You?

How gay are you? Take our quiz and find out

http://www.sciammind.com/page.cfm?section=quiz

As editor of "Psychology Today," Epstein was roundly criticized for supporting conversion therapy. This latest article is yet another defense of the ex-gay movement.
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 2/18/2006 3:54 PM  

Epstein's quizes are interesting - I will have to look over his homepage more closely. When I took the short How Gay Are You? quiz, I found it extremely skewed. I measured 11 (one step away from 100% homosexual) when in fact I'm happily married to a man, and identify as bisexual. I don't see what the point is of the short quiz - it's totally unreliable. But at least the longer one leaves a little room for reality! That one placed me in the middle of a continuum, where I probably belong.

Susie
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 2/21/2006 1:53 PM  

Post a Comment



<< Home
Archives

January 16, 2005   January 23, 2005   January 30, 2005   February 06, 2005   February 13, 2005   February 20, 2005   February 27, 2005   March 06, 2005   March 13, 2005   March 20, 2005   March 27, 2005   April 03, 2005   April 10, 2005   April 17, 2005   April 24, 2005   May 01, 2005   May 08, 2005   May 15, 2005   May 22, 2005   May 29, 2005   June 05, 2005   June 12, 2005   June 19, 2005   June 26, 2005   July 03, 2005   July 10, 2005   July 17, 2005   July 24, 2005   July 31, 2005   August 07, 2005   August 14, 2005   August 21, 2005   August 28, 2005   September 04, 2005   September 11, 2005   September 18, 2005   September 25, 2005   October 02, 2005   October 09, 2005   October 16, 2005   October 23, 2005   October 30, 2005   November 06, 2005   November 13, 2005   November 20, 2005   November 27, 2005   December 04, 2005   December 11, 2005   December 18, 2005   December 25, 2005   January 01, 2006   January 08, 2006   January 15, 2006   January 22, 2006   January 29, 2006   February 05, 2006   February 12, 2006   February 19, 2006   February 26, 2006   March 05, 2006   March 12, 2006   March 19, 2006   March 26, 2006   April 02, 2006   April 09, 2006   April 16, 2006   April 23, 2006   April 30, 2006   May 07, 2006   May 14, 2006   May 21, 2006   May 28, 2006   June 04, 2006   June 11, 2006   June 18, 2006   June 25, 2006   July 02, 2006   July 09, 2006   July 16, 2006   July 23, 2006   July 30, 2006   August 06, 2006   August 13, 2006   August 20, 2006   August 27, 2006   September 03, 2006   September 10, 2006   September 17, 2006   September 24, 2006   October 01, 2006   October 08, 2006   October 15, 2006   October 22, 2006   October 29, 2006   November 05, 2006   November 12, 2006   November 19, 2006   November 26, 2006   December 03, 2006   December 10, 2006   December 17, 2006   December 31, 2006   January 07, 2007   January 14, 2007   January 21, 2007   January 28, 2007   February 04, 2007   February 11, 2007   February 18, 2007   February 25, 2007   March 04, 2007   March 11, 2007   March 18, 2007   March 25, 2007   April 01, 2007   April 08, 2007   April 15, 2007   April 22, 2007   April 29, 2007   May 06, 2007   May 13, 2007   May 20, 2007   May 27, 2007   June 03, 2007   June 10, 2007   June 17, 2007   June 24, 2007   July 01, 2007   July 08, 2007   July 15, 2007   July 22, 2007   July 29, 2007   August 05, 2007   August 12, 2007   August 19, 2007   August 26, 2007   September 02, 2007   September 09, 2007   September 16, 2007   September 23, 2007   September 30, 2007   October 07, 2007   October 14, 2007   October 21, 2007   October 28, 2007   November 04, 2007   November 11, 2007   November 18, 2007   November 25, 2007   December 02, 2007   December 09, 2007   December 16, 2007   December 23, 2007   December 30, 2007   January 06, 2008   January 13, 2008   January 20, 2008   January 27, 2008   February 03, 2008   February 10, 2008   February 17, 2008   February 24, 2008   March 02, 2008   March 09, 2008   March 16, 2008   March 23, 2008   March 30, 2008   April 06, 2008   April 13, 2008   April 20, 2008   April 27, 2008   May 04, 2008   May 11, 2008   May 18, 2008   May 25, 2008   June 01, 2008   June 08, 2008   June 15, 2008   June 22, 2008   June 29, 2008   July 06, 2008   July 13, 2008   July 20, 2008   July 27, 2008   August 03, 2008   August 10, 2008   August 17, 2008   August 24, 2008   August 31, 2008   September 07, 2008   September 14, 2008   September 21, 2008   September 28, 2008   October 05, 2008   October 12, 2008   October 19, 2008   October 26, 2008   November 02, 2008   November 09, 2008   November 16, 2008   November 23, 2008   November 30, 2008   December 07, 2008   December 14, 2008   December 21, 2008   December 28, 2008   January 04, 2009   January 11, 2009   January 18, 2009   January 25, 2009   February 01, 2009   February 08, 2009   February 15, 2009   February 22, 2009   March 01, 2009   March 08, 2009   March 15, 2009   March 22, 2009   March 29, 2009   April 05, 2009   April 12, 2009   April 19, 2009   April 26, 2009   May 03, 2009   May 10, 2009   May 17, 2009   May 24, 2009   May 31, 2009   June 07, 2009   June 14, 2009   June 21, 2009   June 28, 2009   July 12, 2009   July 19, 2009   July 26, 2009   August 02, 2009   August 09, 2009   August 16, 2009   August 23, 2009   August 30, 2009   September 06, 2009   September 13, 2009   September 20, 2009   September 27, 2009   October 04, 2009   October 11, 2009   October 18, 2009   November 01, 2009   November 08, 2009   November 15, 2009   November 22, 2009   December 06, 2009   December 13, 2009   December 20, 2009   December 27, 2009   January 17, 2010   January 24, 2010   January 31, 2010   February 07, 2010   February 14, 2010   February 21, 2010   March 21, 2010   April 18, 2010   June 06, 2010   July 18, 2010   July 25, 2010   October 31, 2010   December 19, 2010   April 10, 2011  

Join Wayne's Email List
Email:





Daily Commentary
RSS Feed: RSS Feed





Truth Wins Out