Wayne Besen - Daily Commentary

Wednesday, April 19, 2006

(Weekly Column)

When fundamentalists are confronted with evidence that contradicts religious dogma, they like to dismiss the inconvenient facts by saying that God is testing their faith. But in the past few weeks, God has given the faithful so many tests, that President Bush ought to appoint Him to run "No Child Left Behind."

First, the right wing was presented with a crushing $2.5 million study that said the power of group prayer was ineffective and provided no benefit to patients recovering from cardiac bypass surgery. In fact, 59 percent of patients who knew they were being prayed for had complications, compared to 51 percent of the patients who did not receive prayers. A few more of these studies and patients will pray that no one is praying for them. Of course, prayer can be a positive force, but it should be a humble and reverent matter, not the showy and superstitious domain of the audacious and ostentatious.

If you think about it, this study makes a lot of sense, with prayer often leading to the law of unintended consequences. For example, in the past two decades countless teams of Neo-Puritans have prayed for homosexuals to be delivered out of "bondage." In that same time period, however, the number of gay men and women who are just plain out has increased dramatically.

In another divine test, a 375 million year old fossil was found that scientists say is a long-sought missing link in the evolution from fish to walking life forms. Before the discovery, advocates of Intelligent Design had claimed that the fact such a link was missing undermined the theory of Evolution. I guess medieval minds will go back to the drawing board to dream up their next Creationist scheme.

Meanwhile, we have learned that Judas may not have been a betrayer of Jesus, but his best friend. The Gospel of Judas is particularly devastating to fundamentalism because it shows their religion is not as absolute as they suggest. The idea of preaching God's "word" becomes questionable when we keep digging up new words.

Who is to say that we won't stumble upon a hidden text buried in a Vatican vault where Paul comes out of the closet and goes to a circuit party in Babylon? Or maybe we will come to find that Sodom was not actually destroyed, but gentrified by gays and the writers of the Old Testament were simply bitter because they were priced out of their apartments.

Neo-Puritans might want to escape the modern world by retreating to the comfortable confines of Wal-Mart. But inside the Big Box are little boxes stuffed with DVDs of Brokeback Mountain. And coming soon to the Big Screen is the Da Vinci Code, starring Tom Hanks, which will have religious conservatives reeling.

When all else fails, the right wing will return to gay bashing, which is what it intends to do as midterm elections approach. However, there is even bad news on this front. A new Pew Research Center for the People and the Press poll shows that only 51 percent of people oppose allowing gay people the freedom to marry, compared to a whopping 63 percent in 2004. At this rate, Pat Robertson will be performing gay weddings by 2010.

In search of a new scapegoat, conservatives thought they had a sure winner in Mexican-bashing. What they did not expect was that the people who cleaned their houses, would clean their clocks in the battle over public opinion. Hundreds of thousands of immigrants attended boisterous protest rallies across America, causing angst among GOP political operatives who are afraid this issue might cost the party Arizona, New Mexico and Nevada in future elections.

If this isn't bad enough, George W. Bush, the man the fundamentalists catapulted into the Oval Office as the "Chosen One" is plummeting in the polls. At the same time, key former Generals are no longer playing ball with Donald Rumsfeld, while Dick Cheney is getting rancorously booed at that great bastion of liberalism - the major league baseball park.

Finally, a new study reported in the Journal of Research Into Personality reveals that confident, resilient, self-reliant kids mostly grow up to be liberals, while whiney, habitual complainers grow up to be conservatives. The existence of Robert Novak, Bill O Reilly and Tucker Carlson seem to back the study's conclusions.

God has tested Neo-Puritans and they have received a report card pockmarked with Fs. A group that anoints itself moral and then chooses Tom DeLay as its prophet and Bush as its savior, can't be surprised when they encounter disasters of biblical proportions.

21 Comments:

While I have no use for fundamentalist religion; I have to say that the 'power of prayer' study had some major flaws it it. Dr. Larry Dossey (no bible beater) has done research and written a number of books supporting the power of prayer in healing and medicine. The difference is though, that his studies involved people who were praying with compassion and love for someone they knew; not the nameless, faceless assemblyline 'prayer' of this study. Before this study was even done, Dossey heard about it and said it will never work and they'll get negative results. Bingo! I'm spiritual but not religious and am glad to see the fundos finally getting the crap kicked out of their pathetically antiquated Weltanschauung!
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 4/19/2006 9:43 AM  

Sounds like the fundos prayers about gays being delivered from bondage is being answered. We're being delivered from THEM more and more everyday.
Gary (NJ)
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 4/19/2006 9:55 AM  

>confident, resilient, self-reliant kids mostly grow up to be liberals, while whiney, habitual complainers grow up to be conservatives.

Oh, that's wonderful! I have fretted a great deal about the direction in which the religious right has taken the country, so this article is very heartening to me.
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 4/19/2006 10:14 AM  

The Neo-Puritans seem to violate virtually every core value of what I learned of Christianity (although it WAS in a Catholic high school): compassion, forgiveness, peace, humility, and most especially, love for your fellow man. Granted, this means nothing coming from an ex-Catholic-turned-pagan-humanist, but I do find it interesting.

--Johnny in Minneapolis
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 4/19/2006 10:50 AM  

When I was young, repressed and growing up in a small southern town I used to pray so hard for God to make me straight, like the other boys. Now that I'm out and living an honest life, I believe my prayers were answered, just not in the way I intended when I was a kid. That's what I believe is happening to all those fundamentalist prayers for gays to change. God is hearing them and answering them, just not with the answer they want. The answer they're getting is waves of gays coming out and demanding change.
posted by Blogger Sam, at 4/19/2006 2:04 PM  

If you’re looking for a book which points out inaccuracies in the Bible, read THE SINS OF SCRIPTURE by John Shelby Spong. He details how fundamentalists throughout the ages have used the Bible to further their own misogynist, homophobic, bigoted and anti-Semitic agenda.
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 4/19/2006 5:20 PM  

First of all it is a pleasure to see an intelligent article and comments that doesn't Blame OR Include "ALL" Christians for the actions of this petty, selfish, arrogant group of Fundamentalist, expecially since the Progressives have been trying so hard to distance themselves from these hair brain radicals/Extremists!

Prayer in my opinion, is very helpful for those people you know and friends of people you know. It makes them feel good to know someone else is thinking of them and wishing them well which lessens their anxiety and helps in the mental healing process. A healthy mind and attitude helps in the healing and if that person dies, then it was a way of relieving their anxiety to their end. The saying goes, that even though it seems that GOD does not listen to your prayers HE is still there and is still lisenting. The end result is, what ever happens, happens.
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 4/19/2006 7:51 PM  

I admit this is well written. But in the end, the queers will pay when they meet there maker. No fancy words will keep you people from the underworld of fire below.

I can look forward to heaven as a Christian, can you?

Duke K.
Indiana
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 4/19/2006 9:18 PM  

If heaven is filled with self righteous, hateful bogots like Duke K- count me out.
jaylen in San Diego
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 4/19/2006 10:03 PM  

of course I meant biggots
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 4/19/2006 10:06 PM  

DUKE SAID:
"I admit this is well written. But in the end, the queers will pay when they meet there maker. No fancy words will keep you people from the underworld of fire below.
I can look forward to heaven as a Christian, can you?"
Duke K.
Indiana
*********************************
AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA, ROTFLMAO!!

Duke, that's where you're fundamentally wrong. WE'LL ALL be heaven you moron. GOD accepts everyone, even the likes of YOU, bigot!! But I'm sure sometime before you get there you'll go through hell first for your stupidity (1) and (2)for constantly misquoting Jesus in the New Testament. Remember HIS greatest Commandment moron? So I guess you just don't love yourself at all.
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 4/20/2006 12:49 AM  

Duke must feel much pain. In my town there are many Christians who feel that the flaws that desecrate modern life are the fault of many. We are being called by ministers who claim Jesus. They do not know Jesus.

They are crying out for people to cease using scripture to demean people - to demean and question our humanity - the humanity of all.

Their lives are filling with the love of many who have been hurt by modern society, and in equal measure have been hurt deeply by hateful reading of scripture.

They welcome - they provide the hospitality that was lacking in Sodom - turning people away, closing the gates to the 'stranger', wishing to take advantage of the beautiful.

Wayne, you are beautiful. You would have been like an angel in Sodom.

Duke must know his sin.

Can we all welcome him? This is the most difficult thing for those of us who listen to our hearts, our minds, our souls, and our principles. It's even more complicated when we listen for the sacred wisdom of the texts. They are not clear but our protests to Duke share the voice of prophets of old, railing against a system that demeans us all.

Some of us have moved beyond our meanness, as the Reverend Doctor Martin Luther King Junior would have wanted.
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 4/20/2006 1:36 AM  

The only 'fire below' in Duke's life is, undoubtedly, the big dick he's getting shoved up his ass behind closed doors after his sanctimonious postings on the site.
B. Queer
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 4/20/2006 9:20 AM  

No 'fancy words' Duke?! You remind me of the fat obnoxious redneck in the hirin' trailer in Brokeback Mountain.
Gary (NJ)
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 4/20/2006 9:22 AM  

Duke,

If your Heaven is filled with people like you, I embrace Hell gladly. I would hate to spend eternity with millions of people as ignorant, bigoted, and hateful as you. In fact, I'm pretty sure I have a penthouse overlooking the Lake of Fire waiting for me.

--Johnny in Minneapolis
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 4/20/2006 10:41 AM  

Threats of hell reveal the most about fundamentalists - they have no other power than to threaten people into submission. How sad that such superstition still works on as many people as it does.

Hell is only as real as you believe it to be. I'll stick with reason.
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 4/20/2006 11:32 AM  

Ok, folks, to be fair to Duke, he didn't talk about Hell. So let's not put words in his mouth.

And Duke, to answer your question: yeah. I'm a Christian and I believe that after this life I'll be with God. But I certainly don't live my life based on a reward/punishment system.

If I thought I'd get to heaven by restricting the neighborhoods that Jews could live in, I still wouldn't do it. If I thought I'd avoid Hell by supporting the Bible-sanctioned institution of slavery, I'd risk Hell. If I thought God wanted me to set up one set of laws for straight people and another for gay people, I'd say I had no use for that type of god.

Sometimes you have to do what's right even in the face of "eternal punishment".

However, I don't think that God answers to the conservative Christian politicians. And I don't take my religous instruction from those who were completely wrong on slavery, civil rights, treatment of other faiths, and just about every other social issue you can think of.

So I'll do what I believe to be moral (oddly enough, it's consistent with the teachings of Jesus). I'll treat people with respect and equality. And I'll leave the judging to God.

(my appologies to those who aren't Christian - not trying to proselytize or exclude anyone)

Timothy Kincaid
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 4/23/2006 7:55 PM  

As a Christian, I believe in God. And I think he has a very ironic and twisted sense of humor.

Just about the time some televangelist says that God's going to send hurricanes to punish the gays, a hurricane rips the roof off of Coral Ridge's big anti-gay church. And let some right-wing nut start in about "sinners" and you just know that his orgy with underage hookers is going to hit the news.

So I think maybe we should start a campaign to pray that "God changes the hearts of the voters to fight the evils of gay marriage." We'd probably have full marriage equality by the end of the year - and you know God will be laughing.

Timothy Kincaid
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 4/23/2006 8:05 PM  

TIMOTHY KINKAID SAID: "Ok, folks, to be fair to Duke, he didn't talk about Hell. So let's not put words in his mouth".

DUKE SAID: "No fancy words will keep you people from the underworld of fire below". AND:
"I can look forward to heaven as a Christian, can you"?

NOW what exactly is the underworld of fire below if not HELL? Also in his assertion that HE can look forward to heaven (and his question "can you?" is the implication that (in his opinion)no we can not. Rather we can look forward to an eternity in hell. He may not have used the word Hell but that is just a technicality-really.
Jaylen in San Diego
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 4/24/2006 1:14 PM  

I don't give a hooey about heaven or hell. Living an honest and ethical life for the "now" is enough of a challenge for me. SW
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 4/24/2006 8:16 PM  

Ooooooooooooops

OK... I misspoke on that one. You're right, Duke did talk about the "fire below".

Timothy
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 4/24/2006 9:02 PM  

Post a Comment



<< Home
Archives

January 16, 2005   January 23, 2005   January 30, 2005   February 06, 2005   February 13, 2005   February 20, 2005   February 27, 2005   March 06, 2005   March 13, 2005   March 20, 2005   March 27, 2005   April 03, 2005   April 10, 2005   April 17, 2005   April 24, 2005   May 01, 2005   May 08, 2005   May 15, 2005   May 22, 2005   May 29, 2005   June 05, 2005   June 12, 2005   June 19, 2005   June 26, 2005   July 03, 2005   July 10, 2005   July 17, 2005   July 24, 2005   July 31, 2005   August 07, 2005   August 14, 2005   August 21, 2005   August 28, 2005   September 04, 2005   September 11, 2005   September 18, 2005   September 25, 2005   October 02, 2005   October 09, 2005   October 16, 2005   October 23, 2005   October 30, 2005   November 06, 2005   November 13, 2005   November 20, 2005   November 27, 2005   December 04, 2005   December 11, 2005   December 18, 2005   December 25, 2005   January 01, 2006   January 08, 2006   January 15, 2006   January 22, 2006   January 29, 2006   February 05, 2006   February 12, 2006   February 19, 2006   February 26, 2006   March 05, 2006   March 12, 2006   March 19, 2006   March 26, 2006   April 02, 2006   April 09, 2006   April 16, 2006   April 23, 2006   April 30, 2006   May 07, 2006   May 14, 2006   May 21, 2006   May 28, 2006   June 04, 2006   June 11, 2006   June 18, 2006   June 25, 2006   July 02, 2006   July 09, 2006   July 16, 2006   July 23, 2006   July 30, 2006   August 06, 2006   August 13, 2006   August 20, 2006   August 27, 2006   September 03, 2006   September 10, 2006   September 17, 2006   September 24, 2006   October 01, 2006   October 08, 2006   October 15, 2006   October 22, 2006   October 29, 2006   November 05, 2006   November 12, 2006   November 19, 2006   November 26, 2006   December 03, 2006   December 10, 2006   December 17, 2006   December 31, 2006   January 07, 2007   January 14, 2007   January 21, 2007   January 28, 2007   February 04, 2007   February 11, 2007   February 18, 2007   February 25, 2007   March 04, 2007   March 11, 2007   March 18, 2007   March 25, 2007   April 01, 2007   April 08, 2007   April 15, 2007   April 22, 2007   April 29, 2007   May 06, 2007   May 13, 2007   May 20, 2007   May 27, 2007   June 03, 2007   June 10, 2007   June 17, 2007   June 24, 2007   July 01, 2007   July 08, 2007   July 15, 2007   July 22, 2007   July 29, 2007   August 05, 2007   August 12, 2007   August 19, 2007   August 26, 2007   September 02, 2007   September 09, 2007   September 16, 2007   September 23, 2007   September 30, 2007   October 07, 2007   October 14, 2007   October 21, 2007   October 28, 2007   November 04, 2007   November 11, 2007   November 18, 2007   November 25, 2007   December 02, 2007   December 09, 2007   December 16, 2007   December 23, 2007   December 30, 2007   January 06, 2008   January 13, 2008   January 20, 2008   January 27, 2008   February 03, 2008   February 10, 2008   February 17, 2008   February 24, 2008   March 02, 2008   March 09, 2008   March 16, 2008   March 23, 2008   March 30, 2008   April 06, 2008   April 13, 2008   April 20, 2008   April 27, 2008   May 04, 2008   May 11, 2008   May 18, 2008   May 25, 2008   June 01, 2008   June 08, 2008   June 15, 2008   June 22, 2008   June 29, 2008   July 06, 2008   July 13, 2008   July 20, 2008   July 27, 2008   August 03, 2008   August 10, 2008   August 17, 2008   August 24, 2008   August 31, 2008   September 07, 2008   September 14, 2008   September 21, 2008   September 28, 2008   October 05, 2008   October 12, 2008   October 19, 2008   October 26, 2008   November 02, 2008   November 09, 2008   November 16, 2008   November 23, 2008   November 30, 2008   December 07, 2008   December 14, 2008   December 21, 2008   December 28, 2008   January 04, 2009   January 11, 2009   January 18, 2009   January 25, 2009   February 01, 2009   February 08, 2009   February 15, 2009   February 22, 2009   March 01, 2009   March 08, 2009   March 15, 2009   March 22, 2009   March 29, 2009   April 05, 2009   April 12, 2009   April 19, 2009   April 26, 2009   May 03, 2009   May 10, 2009   May 17, 2009   May 24, 2009   May 31, 2009   June 07, 2009   June 14, 2009   June 21, 2009   June 28, 2009   July 12, 2009   July 19, 2009   July 26, 2009   August 02, 2009   August 09, 2009   August 16, 2009   August 23, 2009   August 30, 2009   September 06, 2009   September 13, 2009   September 20, 2009   September 27, 2009   October 04, 2009   October 11, 2009   October 18, 2009   November 01, 2009   November 08, 2009   November 15, 2009   November 22, 2009   December 06, 2009   December 13, 2009   December 20, 2009   December 27, 2009   January 17, 2010   January 24, 2010   January 31, 2010   February 07, 2010   February 14, 2010   February 21, 2010   March 21, 2010   April 18, 2010   June 06, 2010   July 18, 2010   July 25, 2010   October 31, 2010   December 19, 2010   April 10, 2011  

Join Wayne's Email List
Email:





Daily Commentary
RSS Feed: RSS Feed





Truth Wins Out