Wayne Besen - Daily Commentary

Monday, May 14, 2007


(Weekly Column)

Last week, Rudolph Giuliani defined the pro-choice position as succinctly as any abortion rights group in America. However, in doing so, he also defined himself as the religious right's Public Enemy Number One. With Giuliani's shedding of conservative garb, his candidacy now takes on historic dimensions, as he fights to become the first Republican in modern times to win the Republican nomination without the Religious Right's blessing.

At the start of his campaign, Rudy seemed uncharacteristically indecisive, as he vacillated and equivocated until he was in danger of becoming emasculated. As much as Giuliani likes drag, social conservatism was one dress that never quite fit. For the first time in his career, Giuliani looked uncomfortable in his own skin and it was never more apparent than during the first GOP presidential debate, where it was downright painful to watch him dissemble on social issues.

What Giuliani quickly learned was that bulls don't dance well in china shops, nor do they walk particularly well on eggshells. With his record on gay equality, gun control and abortion, he could promise to change the name of the Big Apple to the Big Peach to win Georgia, and would still be distrusted by a majority of southern Republicans.

To have a shot at winning, Rudy had to be Rudy - the Libertarian bully who ran the libertine out of Times Square. After all, what was the point of sucking up to Focus on the Family, when he wants the public and media to focus on anything but his dysfunctional family?

What Giuliani actually said when outlining his position on abortion was rather bold, eloquent and remarkable for its candor.

"I think [abortion] is morally wrong," said Giuliani. "I think ultimately even if you disagree, you have to respect the fact that their conscience is as strong as yours about this, and they're the ones that are most affected by it. So, therefore I would grant women the right to make that choice."

With that statement, the current frontrunner just stuck his thumb in the large eye of the 800-pound religious right Cyclops, which responded with blind fury.

"The mayor's position on abortion couldn't be more repugnant to pro-lifers," carped Richard Land of the Southern Baptist Convention. "It shows a moral obtuseness that is stunning."

A Giuliani victory in the primaries would be a significant victory for gay rights, in that his elevation as the nominee would only occur over the Religious Right's dead body. This would produce the first Republican torchbearer who was not beholden to the Jerry Falwell crowd. Even more delicious, is the prospect of right wing voters having to choose between two despised New Yorkers, Giuliani and their Satan - Hillary Clinton.

This match-up would be a dream for the GLBT community, because it would be the first election without a feast or famine outcome. If Giuliani were elected, we might see a Democratic Congress pass hate crime legislation and the Employment Non-Discrimination Act, with a Republican President signing it, adding heft to its passage. If Clinton won, the same legislation would sail through. They are both opposed to marriage, so that is a moot point, with most of the activity on this issue occurring in the states.

With an acceptable Republican on GLBT issues, gay voters would finally get the luxury of casting their votes solely on other matters, such as taxes, Iraq and healthcare. On these concerns, there are vast differences among the candidates, and Giuliani's unwavering support for the war and his closeness to Bush might undo him, even if the Religious Right can't.

What Giuliani did was take a huge gamble that the Religious Right has been so weakened that moderate Republicans combined with Wall Street money can overcome their strenuous objections. The recent closing of Coral Ridge Ministries' Center for Reclaiming America for Christ is further evidence of the declining power of the far right. Still, even as the "Out of Business" sign was taped to the Center's door, three Republicans professed that they did not believe in evolution during the GOP presidential debate, showing that the Religious Right can still flex its considerable muscle.

While the Democratic primary is more interesting, with several attractive, charismatic candidates, Giuliani's fate should be the primary concern of GLBT voters. Rudy will either break the Religious Right's monopoly over the GOP or they will brutally abort his campaign over his pro-choice position. The outcome of this grueling battle will determine whether the Republican Party finally evolves, or whether we will see more candidates who don't subscribe to the theory of evolution.

14 Comments:

ALL republicans are SCUM.....Don't ever forget it!

Marv
L.A.
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 5/15/2007 1:14 AM  

Well, I sure wouldn't want Giuliano as president, much less Clinton, both of whom aren't so far apart on most issues. Why settle for four more years of the same? Independents and Greens have a far better platform and most of us are not brave enough to get behind them to put a dent in both of the major parties. At least the Greens and some Independents support full equality which the others don't. They'd rather court their larger more powerful hetero constituents to get elected at any price, giving us the shaft in the process. Voting for them just to get this current regime out isn't necessarily the way to go either. Nothing much is going to change if Clinton wins the White House, make no mistake about that.

Robert, NYC.
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 5/15/2007 8:34 AM  

Oooooops, I meant to have said "Giuliani" in my previous comment, sorry for the typo.

Robert, NYC.
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 5/15/2007 8:34 AM  

If he wins, Giuliani could at least be both president and first lady at the same time.
Gary (NJ)
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 5/15/2007 9:04 AM  

Gary, what a nightmare that would be, lol! Dame Edna would have competition for sure!

Robert, NYC.
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 5/15/2007 11:13 AM  

Off topic: i just heard on the radio that jerry falwell was found unconscious in his office this morning and is in 'grave condition'. Hopefully this piece of shit blight on humanity and constant spewer of hate against gay people will soon be worm food!
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 5/15/2007 1:12 PM  

Latest on falwell: ding dong the witch is dead!
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 5/15/2007 1:48 PM  

Any New Yorker can tell you that Giuliani is an authortarian bully. He'd be worse than Bush because he has a brain.

He is also a hypocrite is some respects...has the "liberal" media forgotten to remind everyone that after he dumped his wife on live TV that he went to live with a gay couple? Kindness should be returned in kind, but Guiliani is still against gay marriage, but obviously for having as many as he wants.
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 5/16/2007 10:51 AM  

Why settle for half-measures offered by Republican Giuliani and Democratic Clinton when you can have Ron Paul and Mike Gravel or, because they are longshots, the best candidate available, Al Gore who can actually save democracy from those cons now trying to destroy it.
posted by Blogger Unknown, at 5/17/2007 11:59 AM  

What I find odd about Giuliani in general as a socalled "catholic" is...how was he able to divorce two wives? He married his first cousin, got rid of her then married Donna Hanover whom he later divorced. So much for Gays having a negative impact on the institution of marriage. Since there is no divorce in the RC Church, if a Catholic goes ahead and seeks a divorce, then he or she is automatically excommunicated. Did the Vatican collude and grant annulments on both counts? How is it that the Vatican threatens politicians in Brazil with excommunication if [they] support abortion rights and marriage equality but say nothing to our own catholic republican politicians who may support gay rights and are pro-choice yet threatened John Kerry during the 2004 election, Mario Cuomo, the former Governor of NY State and Geraldine Ferraro and others simply because they supported a woman's right to choose? Years ago, the church would only grant annulments if either party were gay; there was no consummation of the marriage, one party refused to have sex or children, or one party had no intention of marrying in the first place. I find it all hypocritical and Giuliani even more so. No republican in the White House could ever be a good thing for us or for our society.

Robert, NYC.
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 5/17/2007 12:24 PM  

I wish Guiliani were in favor of marriage. Hell, I wish ANY presidential candidate in either party with any chance of winning was in favor of marriage. And I wish Rudy didn't think NH's Civil Unions "went too far".

But I did love that in the last debate when he was accused about five times of being "pro-gay" he never found it necessary to say "yeah, but I oppose marriage". He didn't blink or flinch or act like it was particularly interesting that he's pro-gay.

It will be a wonderful day for all of us on the day that all Republican candidates think it perfectly normal to be pro-gay.
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 5/18/2007 6:03 PM  

my wow gold
cheapest wow power leveling
posted by Anonymous Anonymous, at 8/05/2009 3:15 AM  

There is a cool range of nike air force 1 available including the latest Classic Cardy Style in Black, mens prada shoes, Oatmeal or Cream. These ugg store are almost impossible to get anywhere in the UK and sold out on the cheap Tiffany website within weeks. They are incredibly popular ugg store and its easy to see why. ugg discount is a really versatile boot UGG Bailey Button boots. The three chunky wooden ugg boots Boots Salep the side mean that you can wear them either buttoned up or down and they look great with buy ugg boots.he ultimate in luxury designer clothing has to still be the online shopping Australia boots. These timeless classics are available in nike shoes, Black and Sand these converse shoes really are the last word in comfort footwear. These ugg discount are made entirely from sheepskin with a light Eva sole there is nothing quite Tiffany earring like the feeling of slipping your feet into a brand new pair of ugg boots! But not only do they feel great cheap ugg they look great ugg discount too and can be worn tall or ugg down to expose the sheepskin fur.If you're looking for wholesale supplier for a special lady,discount af1 shoes sale recommend UGG Suburb Crochet from the prada shoesCollection-they have the qualities of great fashion ugg boots online and practicality combined-along with exquisite comfort. If you want to purchase the Tiffany jewelry, please visit ugg classic our online buy ugg boots shop. Welcome to select and buy ugg store!was shocked. But here was a statement ugg shoes that could be checked against future events retail supplies.
posted by Blogger Unknown, at 12/28/2009 1:27 PM  

Everything will be all right,I am behind you.Mentioned that ed hardy jeans, more than most young people loveed hardy uk, it is hot in Hollywooded hardy bags, popular brands, Brittany Spears, Paris Hilton, David Beckham, Ewan McGregor, Usher ...... list goes on, even in Asia the trend has been to guide star Ed Hardy is difficult to resist the charm, Rain love retro Punk, ed hardy shirts love is also a private users, BoA, Lee Minwoo, Jolin had appeared wearing Jeans G Star, Lee Hom Heroes of the album in a tiger is the diamond net hat Ed Hardy's headed merchandise.G Star saleis a frontrunner in the denim design race. For their Fall 2010 Collection, they are presenting the elegant and more sophisticated side of denim: “The G-Star Fall/Winter 2010 G Star shop and G Star jeans Collections demonstrates the fusion of denim G Star jacket, elegant tailoring and sophisticated silhouettes in vibrant colors. G Star t shirts metallic washes and treatments G Star clothing the collections,G Star shoes highlighting the inventive and truly original aesthetic that is distinctively G Star raw clothing.The urban feel that is always G Star raw jacket is still present, but the G Star raw jeans and lines are clean and can serve as perfect additions to your G Star raw denim.G Star raw t shirts’s Fall 2010 Collection makes its debut in 8 days. Stay tuned for G Star raw shoes review.Tiffany jewellery uk, a symbol of American design. With love and beauty,Tiffany jewellery sale romance and dreams as the theme,shamwow but the wind reputation for nearly two centuries.
posted by Blogger Unknown, at 2/24/2010 8:53 PM  

Post a Comment



<< Home
Archives

January 16, 2005   January 23, 2005   January 30, 2005   February 06, 2005   February 13, 2005   February 20, 2005   February 27, 2005   March 06, 2005   March 13, 2005   March 20, 2005   March 27, 2005   April 03, 2005   April 10, 2005   April 17, 2005   April 24, 2005   May 01, 2005   May 08, 2005   May 15, 2005   May 22, 2005   May 29, 2005   June 05, 2005   June 12, 2005   June 19, 2005   June 26, 2005   July 03, 2005   July 10, 2005   July 17, 2005   July 24, 2005   July 31, 2005   August 07, 2005   August 14, 2005   August 21, 2005   August 28, 2005   September 04, 2005   September 11, 2005   September 18, 2005   September 25, 2005   October 02, 2005   October 09, 2005   October 16, 2005   October 23, 2005   October 30, 2005   November 06, 2005   November 13, 2005   November 20, 2005   November 27, 2005   December 04, 2005   December 11, 2005   December 18, 2005   December 25, 2005   January 01, 2006   January 08, 2006   January 15, 2006   January 22, 2006   January 29, 2006   February 05, 2006   February 12, 2006   February 19, 2006   February 26, 2006   March 05, 2006   March 12, 2006   March 19, 2006   March 26, 2006   April 02, 2006   April 09, 2006   April 16, 2006   April 23, 2006   April 30, 2006   May 07, 2006   May 14, 2006   May 21, 2006   May 28, 2006   June 04, 2006   June 11, 2006   June 18, 2006   June 25, 2006   July 02, 2006   July 09, 2006   July 16, 2006   July 23, 2006   July 30, 2006   August 06, 2006   August 13, 2006   August 20, 2006   August 27, 2006   September 03, 2006   September 10, 2006   September 17, 2006   September 24, 2006   October 01, 2006   October 08, 2006   October 15, 2006   October 22, 2006   October 29, 2006   November 05, 2006   November 12, 2006   November 19, 2006   November 26, 2006   December 03, 2006   December 10, 2006   December 17, 2006   December 31, 2006   January 07, 2007   January 14, 2007   January 21, 2007   January 28, 2007   February 04, 2007   February 11, 2007   February 18, 2007   February 25, 2007   March 04, 2007   March 11, 2007   March 18, 2007   March 25, 2007   April 01, 2007   April 08, 2007   April 15, 2007   April 22, 2007   April 29, 2007   May 06, 2007   May 13, 2007   May 20, 2007   May 27, 2007   June 03, 2007   June 10, 2007   June 17, 2007   June 24, 2007   July 01, 2007   July 08, 2007   July 15, 2007   July 22, 2007   July 29, 2007   August 05, 2007   August 12, 2007   August 19, 2007   August 26, 2007   September 02, 2007   September 09, 2007   September 16, 2007   September 23, 2007   September 30, 2007   October 07, 2007   October 14, 2007   October 21, 2007   October 28, 2007   November 04, 2007   November 11, 2007   November 18, 2007   November 25, 2007   December 02, 2007   December 09, 2007   December 16, 2007   December 23, 2007   December 30, 2007   January 06, 2008   January 13, 2008   January 20, 2008   January 27, 2008   February 03, 2008   February 10, 2008   February 17, 2008   February 24, 2008   March 02, 2008   March 09, 2008   March 16, 2008   March 23, 2008   March 30, 2008   April 06, 2008   April 13, 2008   April 20, 2008   April 27, 2008   May 04, 2008   May 11, 2008   May 18, 2008   May 25, 2008   June 01, 2008   June 08, 2008   June 15, 2008   June 22, 2008   June 29, 2008   July 06, 2008   July 13, 2008   July 20, 2008   July 27, 2008   August 03, 2008   August 10, 2008   August 17, 2008   August 24, 2008   August 31, 2008   September 07, 2008   September 14, 2008   September 21, 2008   September 28, 2008   October 05, 2008   October 12, 2008   October 19, 2008   October 26, 2008   November 02, 2008   November 09, 2008   November 16, 2008   November 23, 2008   November 30, 2008   December 07, 2008   December 14, 2008   December 21, 2008   December 28, 2008   January 04, 2009   January 11, 2009   January 18, 2009   January 25, 2009   February 01, 2009   February 08, 2009   February 15, 2009   February 22, 2009   March 01, 2009   March 08, 2009   March 15, 2009   March 22, 2009   March 29, 2009   April 05, 2009   April 12, 2009   April 19, 2009   April 26, 2009   May 03, 2009   May 10, 2009   May 17, 2009   May 24, 2009   May 31, 2009   June 07, 2009   June 14, 2009   June 21, 2009   June 28, 2009   July 12, 2009   July 19, 2009   July 26, 2009   August 02, 2009   August 09, 2009   August 16, 2009   August 23, 2009   August 30, 2009   September 06, 2009   September 13, 2009   September 20, 2009   September 27, 2009   October 04, 2009   October 11, 2009   October 18, 2009   November 01, 2009   November 08, 2009   November 15, 2009   November 22, 2009   December 06, 2009   December 13, 2009   December 20, 2009   December 27, 2009   January 17, 2010   January 24, 2010   January 31, 2010   February 07, 2010   February 14, 2010   February 21, 2010   March 21, 2010   April 18, 2010   June 06, 2010   July 18, 2010   July 25, 2010   October 31, 2010   December 19, 2010   April 10, 2011  

Join Wayne's Email List
Email:





Daily Commentary
RSS Feed: RSS Feed





Truth Wins Out